Friday, October 21, 2005

Valley of Power

Last to last evening, I was watching an NDTV program on the quake victims. Basically, one of the worst hit areas In Pakistan - Muzaffarabad - is unreachable thanks to LOC restrictions and the phone lines are down, so this channel had arranged a tele-meeting of sorts for groups of people on both sides. Most people of course enquired about their relatives and they generally got responses on the lines of - no home, bad weather, no food, bad conditions, etc. One person however heard for the first time that his entire family was wiped out - this was a terrible moment and everyone on camera and off it got affected by this bit.

It was so frustrating to watch these two groups having to resort to a tele-meeting thing when they are probably a couple of hundred miles from each other ALL thanks to crappy political statements people are making. Is this the time to be making these?? What kind of people are they? What would they have been doing if any member of their family had been stuck in this sort of a situation or worse, had passed away and there was no way you could reach them not because you didn't want to but you COULDN'T for no ability-related-reasons? It was just deeply sad.

I had hoped to see this disaster becoming a leveler and maybe (miraculously) undoing all the strife and boundaries that have been pounded and propounded over the years. Sadly, nothing of the sort has happened and it's almost seeming like a curse someone has cast (do you cast curses like you do spells?) over the people of Kashmir and thereabouts - you either die by bullets or by disasters such as this...or worst of all, you live days full of terror, hunger, pain, and insecurity for the rest of your life.

Even the militants are doing their bit - soon after the quake - that by the way was supposed to have wiped out many many militant camps - they announced how this was the time to help their 'brothers and sisters' and not a time of violence but fog social work and upliftment. How do they go about dong this? By storming into a Jammu and Kashmir state minister's office and shooting him dead and injuring everyone else there. Social work indeed.

Then I read this article on NYT that someone sent in – It managed to deepen this feeling of sadness and introduced the new feeling of cringe-y embarrassment/shame at a country who is making points at a time it can ill-afford to do so. As a citizen of that country it tells me what my country's priorities are and will be should I ever be in any sort of trouble.

On an analogous-with-parenthood note, this action leaves an indelible scar. On the regular note, speaks eons of the maturity levels that led to this brilliant decision. The irony is that this purportedly roots form aspiring for a seat in the UN Security Council. Is a country that neglects the security of its own country in such a callous manner worthy of it? 'worthy' is stretching it. Does it even deserve more than a snort for this? Come to think of it, I don't care half as much for the reaction to the country as much as I do for those poor people who have got the worst of it - they survived the damn earthquake.

9 Comments:

Blogger illusions said...

Yes it is sad when people have their values ever so messed up. The tragedy is that though the leaders are supposed to project the opinion of the country, I doubt if this being done anywhere...do the majority of Americans/Brits actually support Bush in his Iraq mission? I doubt.

On a totally different not, this is a good example of journalism. I am quite certain Jai would smile at the writing.

21 October, 2005 13:29  
Blogger Straight Curves said...

Well, yes that's true but also, remember there are as many opinions as there are people and in a country with population issues it would be likely to catapult to chaos.

"good example of journalism" - are you referring to the NYT article or this post?

If the post, then far from it - journalists are supposed to convey facts in an unbiased manner - and what I have done is pour my heart out! :)

21 October, 2005 14:09  
Blogger Jabberwock said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

21 October, 2005 16:46  
Blogger Jabberwock said...

By your usual standards this is really not all that heart-outpouring. But as always, I have a problem with the "journalists are supposed to convey facts in an unbiased manner" bit. Compared to what the profession is REALLY like, that's as meaningless a statement as "Human beings are supposed to walk around naked and hunt for their food with clubs". (Now don't give me some spiel about progressing in a positive way etc, you can't really think our species has improved since the Paleolith.)

You should try to get over the idealism about journalism and journalists (I still chuckle when I remember a little something you said when you were at my place last - won't bring it up here, this being a public forum etc)

And not to give you a head-swell or something - but if journalism really was a combination of merit, balanced reportage and honest intention, this post of your would have as good a chance of making it into a newspaper as any other "professionally written" piece.

21 October, 2005 16:48  
Blogger illusions said...

And that, if you haven't caught on, is a compliment from Jabber!

21 October, 2005 17:05  
Blogger Nikhil Pahwa said...

"I had hoped to see this disaster becoming a leveler..."

(You do get my point, yes?)

22 October, 2005 17:20  
Blogger Jabberwock said...

Unrest Cure: ha ha, good one! I didn't notice that.
Smits, you're still one of the great earnestly unintentional comedians of our epoch.

22 October, 2005 21:16  
Blogger Nikhil Pahwa said...

Smits: Going by the recent additions to your blogroll, I take it that you don't agree with what my views on how the Sabnis issue is being handled. Yuss?

J: :)

23 October, 2005 11:22  
Blogger Straight Curves said...

Jabberwock: I still stick to the not-to-be-mentioned-on-a-public-forum thing I said about Journalists. You got to be where I am to know it's import...and that you never will be.

Illusions: You have to know Jabber to know that this be the last thing he could be giving me! :) But thanks for the vote of confidence...

The Unrest Cure: ummm...the earnestly unintentional ignoramus didn';t catch on...except for th tense mismatch...is there more? do, DO tell...(serious) As for your other question, check mail.

24 October, 2005 18:39  

Post a Comment

<< Home